In Harvey v Facey (1893), the court determined that no contract existed between the parties through telegrams. The appellants' inquiry about a property's lowest price was answered with a price quote. The court ruled that without an acceptance from Facey, no binding agreement was formed.
This case law note has been reviewed by a law tutor
🏛️ Court: Privy Council (Jamaica) 🗓️ Judgment Date: 29 July 1893 🗂️ Where Reported: [1893] A.C. 552; [1893] 7 WLUK 139 📍 Jurisdiction: United Kingdom
⚖️ Legal Principles
1️⃣
Communication Does Not Equate to Contract: The case highlights that merely stating a minimum selling price in response to an inquiry does not constitute a binding offer. A clear and explicit acceptance is necessary to establish a legally enforceable contract.